| 
					
						| 
								
									| 
											
												
													| 
															
																
																	|  | 
																			
																				| 
																						
																							|  |  
																							| 
																									
																										| ICSRG Bulletin – May 2025  |  
																										| Latest news on sustainability reporting and governance in Europe and beyond |  
																										|  |  |  |  |  |  |  
											
												
													| 
															
																| EU Omnibus Proposals |  
																| 
																  ‘Stop the Clock’ ApprovedIn late February 2025 the European Commission announced the Omnibus Proposals, the first set of legisaltive proposals to  help realise the Competitiveness Compass. The Questions  and answers on simplification omnibus I and II (Q&A) summarizes  the changes.
 The package includes, amongst other things, a proposal for a Directive  amending the CSRD and the CSDDD (Omnibus II) and a proposal which postpones the  application of all reporting requirements in the CSRD for companies that are  due to report in 2026 and 2027 (so-called wave 2 and 3 companies) and which  postpones the transposition deadline and the first wave of application of the  CSDDD by one year to 2028 (Omnibus I).
 Omnibus I, dubbed ‘stop-the-clock’ proposal, entered into force on 17  April 2025 following its publication in the Official Journal of the EU after approval  by the European Parliament and the European  Council in early April. Member states now have until 31 Dec 2025 to transpose  this into national law. In the meantime some member states continue to progress  transposition  of the CSRD: check out the latest version of Accountancy Europe’s tracker here.
 The table below shows extracts from the Q&A pertaining to the proposed  substanive changes to the CSRD. This DG FISMA newsletter provides a useful summary of the proposals.
 Analysis and Reactions
 This recent ACCA article analyses the proposals in so far as they  impact sustainability reporting. There has been a numerous and widely diverging reactions  to the announcement. As Reuters reported a coalition of  NGOs that has lodged a formal complaint with the European Ombudsman over the  Commission’s proposal centered around three key claims: (1) failure to properly  gather evidence and assess impacts, (2) avoidance of broad consultations and  favoring closed-door meetings dominated by industry voices, and (3) failure to  assess whether the omnibus aligns with the EU's climate neutrality target. The  coalition believes that strong sustainability laws like the CSDDD and CSRD are  key to the EU’s competitive advantage in a global market.
 Meantime, SMEunited and EFAA for SMEs have  welcomed the effort made in the Omnibus proposal to reduce the burden for SMEs, in particular the value chain cap. According to one recent sudy, the Sustainability Transformation Monitor 2025, while most companies see the benefits  of sustainability reporting either as equal to or exceeding the costs, a  significant majority of SMEs believe costs exceed the benefits.
 Timing  and Approval
 As this LinkedIn post explains, shortly after the  adoption of Omnibus I (‘stop-the-clock’), the European Parliament’s Legal  Affairs Committee (JURI) appointed rapporteurs and  commenced negotiating Omnibus II. Final agreement will likely take until the end of  2025. This will then be followed by national transposition and implementation. JURI  is deeply divided over which direction to take. Meantime, the Council of the European Union’s working group  overseeing simplification met to examine a draft document that outlines member  state initial asks on CSRD and CSDDD. They agree with the proposed scope  reduction of CSRD.
 Sustainability Assurance
 
The Omnibus proposal maintains the limited assurance  requirement, proposes no changes to assurance providers, and maintains the EC’s  delegated power to adopt a limited assurance standard, However, the proposal  removes the 2026 deadline for adopting a standard and suggests deleting the  possibility of moving from a requirement for limited assurance to a requirement  for reasonable assurance. The EC intends to issue targeted assurance guidelines  by 2026. Moreover, to protect SMEs it proposes requiring assurance providers to  respect the obligation that companies should not request information from value  chain companies with fewer than 1,000 employees beyond what is included in the VSME. This Corporate Disclosures article  examines the impact of these proposals.
																     
																    
																      
																        | We  have mixed views on the Omnibus proposal. The package fails to recognize and  leverage the competitive advantage to be gained from the EU leading the global  sustainable transition. We welcome the relief they offer SMEs and the  simplification of the sector agnostic ESRS. For companies with up to 1,000  employees we suggest they be required to report on the basis of a simplified  standard whose core is based on the voluntary standard for SMEs developed by  EFRAG (EFRAG VSME). |    5. What are the main changes that the  omnibus package is bringing to the CSRD? The omnibus package will bring several  changes to the CSRD, making it more proportionate and easier to implement by  companies:
 
                                                                    Reduction of the scope  of reporting companies: The reporting  requirements would only apply to large undertakings with more than 1000  employees (i.e. undertakings that have more than 1000 employees and either a  turnover above EUR 50 million or a balance sheet total above EUR 25 million)  This means that the number of companies in scope will be reduced by about 80%.  The new scope will be more closely aligned with the key scope thresholds of the  CSDDD.    ‘Value chain  cap': For companies which will not be in  the scope of the CSRD any more (up to 1,000 employees ), the Commission will  adopt by delegated act a voluntary reporting standard , based on the standard  for SMEs (VSME) developed by EFRAG. That standard will act as a shield, by  limiting the information that companies or banks falling into the scope of the  CSRD can request from companies  in their value chains with fewer than  1,000 employees..Commission's  commitment to revise the European Sustainability Reporting standards (“ESRS”): The  Commission will revise the delegated act establishing the ESRS, with the aim of  substantially reducing the number of data points, clarifying provisions deemed  unclear, improving consistency with other pieces of legislation and reducing  the number of data points.  Deletion of  sector-specific standards requirement: The  proposal will delete the empowerment for the Commission to adopt  sector-specific standards.Removing the  reasonable assurance standard: The  proposal is removing the possibility for the Commission to propose moving from  a limited assurance requirement to a reasonable assurance requirement.Postponement of  reporting requirements: Today's package  proposes postponing by two years the entry into application of the reporting  requirements for large companies that have not yet started implementing the  CSRD and for listed SMEs (Wave 2 and 3) in order to give time to the   co-legislators to agree to the Commission's proposed substantive  changes.           6. What is the scope of the new  CSRD? Currently, the CSRD applies to all  large companies (defined as companies above two out of the three following  thresholds: €50 million net turnover, €25 million balance sheet total, 250  employees), as well as SMEs whose securities are listed on an EU regulated  market. However, many businesses and industry associations have suggested that  the Commission should revise the scope by excluding the smaller companies.  Mario Draghi's report on competitiveness also highlighted that the rules would  impose a disproportionately high burden on SMEs and small mid-caps than on  larger companies.
 Today's proposal will reduce the  current scope of the CSRD to large companies with more than 1000 employees  (i.e. companies that have more than 1000 employees and either a turnover above  EUR 50 million or a balance sheet above EUR 25 million). Those companies will  be required to report against the European Sustainability Reporting Standards  (ESRS), while these standards will also be revised and simplified.
 Companies outside the scope of CSRD  (companies with up to 1,000 employees) may choose to report voluntarily on the  basis of a simplified voluntary standard to be adopted by the Commission, based  on the voluntary standards for SMEs (VSME) developed by EFRAG.
 The Commission estimates that the  proposal will reduce the number of companies in scope by 80%.
 Source: Questions  and answers on simplification omnibus I and II,  European Commission, 25 February 2025
 |  
																| ESRS Developments |  
																| 
																  Omnibus Implications On 25 April  2025 EFRAG officially submitted its work plan to the  European Commission outlining the steps it will take to fulfil the specific mandate received on 27 March 2025 to  provide technical advice on the revision and simplification of the ESRS by 31  October 2025. The work plan had just been approved by the EFRAG Sustainability  Reporting Board (SRB) at the second attempt: in late February the SRB welcomed  the Ominibus proposals in relation to sustainability reporting. EFRAG has already commenced work. On 8 April EFRAG invited public input via an online questionnaire on potential revisions with a deadline  of 6 May 2025 from all relevant stakeholders and the first wave of  preparers who implemented the standards in their 2024 sustainability reports.  This public call for input complements a series of interviews and workshops  that EFRAG is organising with preparers, auditors and users. In their response Accountancy  Europe have proposed the Commission’s  list of targeted  reviews to ESRS be split into two groups based on the  amendment complexity, with each group following a different due process, as  explained here.
  Sustainability Reporting  Standards for SMEs
 Late  last year EFRAG released the  proposed sustainability reporting standard for voluntary use by non-listed SMEs (ESRS VSME) and submitted it to the Commission together  with a cost benefit analysis (CBA) and basis for conclusions. EFRAG has initiated a range of activities to help raise awareness of and  implement the standard. It has issued educational videos and facilitated  many translations. To help broaden and deepen the  ecosystem supporting the VSME, EFRAG has established the SME Forum and expanded  the VSME Community and has consulted them on proposed guidance on the standard.    EFRAG  Update The March edition of EFRAG’s Monthly Update Podcast for  Sustainability Reporting is available on YouTube or Spotify  The pdf version of the EFRAG  Update for March, spanning financial and sustainability reporting, is here.    EFRAG VSME Webinar On 7 April 2025 EFRAG hosted a webinar, ‘VSME  In Action: Empowering SMEs for a Sustainable Future’ that  attracted over a 1,500 participants. The full recording is here. A summary  report will be published shortly. During the event Sven Genther, Head of Unit, Corporate reporting,  audit and credit rating agencies (FISMA.C.1) explained  that the ‘EFRAG VSME’ will be adopted, with minor changes, by the Commission as  a recommended guidance by June 2025. Then, on conclusion of the legislative  negotiations, the ‘Omnibus VSME’ that is proposed for voluntary use by companies  employing less than 1,000 employees will be developed and, once agreed, follow  the usual due process for EU delegated acts. Many delegates expressed concern that  the ‘EFRAG VSME’ may not be suitable for companies with more than 250  employees. Some delegates proposed adding modules to address this, though others  feared that making the VSME more suitable for larger companies could impair its utility as a value  chain cap for SMEs.   
                                                                    
                                                                      
                                                                        | We welcome the simplification of the sector agnostic ESRS, in particular simplification that will limit the impact on non-lsited SMEs in the value chain. As the VSME may serve as the basis for a standard for voluntary use by companies with 250-1,000 employees EFRAG ought to start considering what this should look like. Additional modules may need to be added. However, it is vital that the value chain cap be limited to the EFRAG VSME. |  
 |  
																| Global Developments in Sustainability Assurance |  
															  | 
															    IFACThe International  Federation of Accountants (IFAC), the International Ethics Standards Board for  Accountants (IESBA) and the International Auditing and Assurance Standards  Board (IAASB) convened a  multi-stakeholder Summit in Paris on 14 April 2025. The Summit focused on the practical  implementation of the new International Ethics Standards for Sustainability Assurance (IESSA) and strengthening engagement with the IESBA and the IAASB. The summit  reaffirmed the important role that global assurance and ethics standards need  to play in building trust in reported sustainability information. Participants agreed  on the need for enhanced coordination among the IESBA, the IAASB and IFAC  leadership to ensure optimal use of limited resources and continued improvement  in the transparency and effectiveness of the due process for standard setting.
 On 4 April 2025 Accountancy Europe and IFAC reaffirmed their commitment to high-quality and consistent sustainability  assurance and say that IAASB’s International  Standard on Sustainability Assurance (ISSA 5000) could fulfil this role.
   IAASB-IESBA Stakeholder Advisory Council (SAC) Meeting The Stakeholder Advisory Council, which meets on 5-6 May 2025 in New York, plays an important role by providing  strategic-level input and recommendations to both IAASB and IESBA. It also  serves as a key forum for engaging with a diverse range of stakeholders. Key  discussion topics include deregulation and its potential implications for the  IAASB and IESBA’s standards, including those relating to sustainability. View  the agenda here and follow along via livestream on YouTube here.   ISSA 5000 Back in January  2025 the IAASB and the IESBA launched a joint effort to support effective  implementation of their landmark standards  aimed at advancing trust and transparency in sustainability reporting and  assurance. The  standards become effective for periods starting on or after 15 December 2026,  with early adoption permitted and encouraged. The  IAASB believes the ISSA 5000 is  scalable and adaptable to regional regulatory requirements, such as the CSRD, and  can be used with any sustainability reporting framework, standard or other  suitable criteria including EFRAG’s VSME, and is applicable to all assurance  providers and for organizations of all sizes. A suite of implementation support  is available here. To support effective implementation stakeholders are  invited to submit implementation questions or matters for the IAASB’s consideration (emulating EFRAG’s Q&A Platform for its ESRS) - read more here.
 CEAOB guidelines on limited assurance on sustainability reporting are available for  CSRD engagements. In addition, the  European Contact Group (ECG) has published illustrative examples of limited  assurance reports for engagements in accordance with the CSRD - see the  unmodified illustrative report here and  the modified illustrative report here. These  examples may require adaptation  to align with specific jurisdictional requirements and standards.
 Based  on its own examination of reports Corporate Disclosures says the early indications are that the Big Four has captured the majority share of  the CSRD assurance market and concludes that the market concentration may be worse  than the financial audit market. This EFAA for SMEs paper looks at the role of small and medium-sized accountancy practices (SMPs) in the  fast emerging market for assurance on sustainability reporting.
   IESSA In lockstep  with the IAASB, the IESBA announced that its new IESSA and  other new sustainability-related provisions establish a strong ethical  foundation for sustainability reporting and assurance engagements. The  IESBA has commenced implementation support activities in earnest including  material that can be access here and a  webinar series on the new standards - access the recordings and  presentation slides here. 
 
                                                                  
                                                                    
                                                                      | We support the timely global adoption and effective implementation of the ISSA 5000 and IESSA but urge close monitoring of the impact on value chain reporting and assurance and taking corrective action as necessary.  |  |  
																| Global Developments in Sustainability Reporting |  
															  | 
															    Disclosure of Carbon Instruments As Corporate Disclosures report while carbon-related instruments - financial and policy tools that are  used to manage, reduce or offset GHG emissions - are increasingly being used to  help businesses meet their climate goals, a study by the Association of  Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) and the University of Glasgow reveals  that most high-emitting companies are not including information on carbon  instruments in their financial statements or annual reports. ISSB  Update
 The ISSB Update, summarising the April 2025 ISSB meeting, is now  available. You can also listen to Chair Emmanuel Faber and Vice-Chair Sue Lloyd  in the latest episode of  the ISSB podcast in which Faber and Lloyd share insights into developments from the  ISSB, including: the recently launched Roadmap Development Tool; the Integrated Thinking and Reporting Conference and stakeholder engagements  in Tokyo; and key takeaways from the April 2025 ISSB meeting.
 Revision of IFRS S2
 In response to market feedback, the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) has published an Exposure Draft (ED) proposing targeted  amendments to IFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures that would provide reliefs to  ease application of some of the requirements related to the disclosure of  greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The ED is open for comment until 27 June  2025. Find out more and submit comments here.
 IFRS S3
 At a recent conference held by Institute of Chartered  Accountants of Scotland on 23 April 2025 Corporate  Disclosures heard  that the ISSB has not started standard setting activitity for an IFRS S3, and  there is at this stage no clarity on how many standards it intends to issue,  within which timeline, and indeed what the overall architecture of that body of  work would look like.
 IFRS Foundation  Adoption and Implementation Support
 The IFRS Foundation continues to provide and enhance adoption  and implementation support. It has now held nine webinars on in its sustainability disclosure series,  “Perspectives on Sustainability Disclosure”. Links to the slides and recording are now available for the latest webinar on  'Ramping up systems and processes for sustainability data’. The IFRS Foundation has also made it possible to access  SASB Standards in both PDF and HTML formats, free of charge for non-commercial  use, in the new SASB Standards Navigator. Following the publication of educational  material on ‘Sustainability-related risks and opportunities and the disclosure of  material information’ the IFRS Foundation has now released a  webcast series to further support  companies with this task. And finally, on 16 April 2025 the IFRS Foundation hosted  the ‘Introduction to IFRS  Sustainability Licensing’ webinar event: links to the slides and recording are now available.
   Due Process Consultation EFRAG has published  its final Comment  Letter on EFRAG on the IFRS Foundation’s proposed amendments to the Due  Process Handbook, released in December 2024. EFRAG’s letter urges, amongst  other things, the development of a conceptual framework dedicated to  sustainability reporting and the establishment of an interpretations committee for  sustainability reporting. 
 
                                                                  
                                                                    
                                                                      | We believe that the IFRS Foundation ought to focus on implementation of its present suite of standards and think about how best to help non-listed SMEs respond to requests for sustainability information from larger companies and finance providers. The VSME developed by EFRAG for the European Commission may have a role to play. The IASB recently updated the IFRS for SMEs, its financial reporting standard for non-publicly accountable entities.  |  |  
																| IFAC and PAOs Supporting the Sustainability Agenda |  
															  | 
															    IFAC’s GHG  EmissionsIFAC and its members, professional accountancy  organizations (PAOs), are working together to promote sustainability. With help  from Greenly, a Certified B-Corp, IFAC is pursuing its own sustainability  targets, measurements, and reporting. IFAC now boasts greater visibility of its  scope 3 emissions, enhanced data quality and detailed emissions tracking, and reduced  emissions through smart technology choices, optimized travel planning and hybrid  working. IFAC invites stakeholders to watch its  testimonial and read its case study to learn how it aligns its  internal operations to complement its advocacy for sustainability reporting and  assurance. IFAC says its aims “to inspire other small associations to be  proactive and not let the pursuit of perfection get in the way of starting!”
 PAOs
 Through a combination of advocacy, education, and  direct action, PAOs are making a meaningful contribution to the sustainability  agenda. Read about the progress several IFAC members have made on their  sustainability journeys here and read this IFAC Gateway article about how PAOs can can lead the way to net zero. IFAC has a catalogue of  publicly available sustainability courses and certifications offered by PAOs on  demand, for a fee or free, to help accountants gain knowledge.
 SMEs
 The IFAC Small Business Sustainability Checklist comes with a dedicated web page that provides material on sustainability  reporting, advisory, assurance, and education and training. An online version of  this checklist is coming soon.
 Revision of  SMOs
 On 14 April 2025 IFAC launched a public consultation on targeted revisions to its  Statements of Membership Obligations (SMOs), a cornerstone of IFAC and its members’ commitment to a  strong and sustainable global accountancy profession. The proposed revision  includes the need for PAOs ro adopt or work toward the adoption of all IFRS  Standards issued by the ISSB. Feedback can be provided via a response template form and the  consultation is open until 8 August 2025. The revised SMOs are expected to  take effect on 1 January 2026. Read more here.
   IESs In late April  2025 IFAC hosted webinars, with translation into multiple languages, on the  revisions to the International Education Standards (IESs) to help stakeholders understand  the changes including those to accommodate sustainability. Recordings in each  language will be available in early May 2025. Read more here. 
 
                                                                  
                                                                    
                                                                      | We believe the accountancy professions must do more, with more urgency, to advocate for and faciliate sustainability. Sustainability is the defining public interest issue of the C21st and the accountancy profession needs to show bold leadership. Moreover, the leadership and convenors of the profession – IFAC, regional network partners and its PAOs – must practice what they preach.  |  |  
																| ACCA Survey – Please Respond by 5 May 2025 |  
															  | 
															    The ACCA has launched a survey designed to  help you evaluate and enhance your readiness to meet the increasing demand for  financial and sustainability information. Respondents will be able to benchmark  their readiness against their peers. The survey will close on 5 May 2025. |  
																| UPCOMING EVENTS |  
															  |  |  
															  | JOIN ICSRG SUSTAINABILITY  FORUM ON LINKEDIN |  |  |  |  |